A couple of weeks ago, I did a comparison of MyFitnessPal and LoseIt!. I was on the fence on which meal tracking app was best for me – I liked some of the features of LoseIt!, but I liked others of MFP.
I will be honest – I had to give up on LoseIt. There were just a few little issues that led me to continue using MyFitnessPal. The “biggest” of these little issues is that I have so much history built up in MFP.
Weight numbers, meals, recipes – there are just so many entries here that the app / website just means that my overall experience is tailored to my personal preferences and tastes just right. You could argue that you can build that same history eventually with another app, but it’s one of those intangibles that is a barrier to entry for some other apps.
It’s the same reason a lot of other people I talked to on Reddit don’t switch to MFP – they’ve built up their own personal history with apps like LoseIt! and FatSecret.
This was another little factor. While LoseIt! synced with my FitBit, MFP offers so many more connectivity options. For a brief period I was without a FitBit, so I was able to sync with Samsung Health (which in itself is a great app). I think MyFitnessPal is always going to win out over the other apps for connectivity, because it’s a much bigger app than the others and more services work with it.
It’s funny – some people consider MFP to be ugly. I think just the opposite – it’s sleek and well-rendered. LoseIt! just doesn’t have the same kind of polish to it. This is definitely the smallest of the little differences, because otherwise the apps function almost identically.
Like I said – my personal choice is MyFitnessPal. If you need to decide which app you want to use – just choose one and go with it. Don’t do what I did and use two apps side-by-side…it gets tedious, and that reduces the likelihood you’ll keep using the app of choice.
If you find that your app of choice isn’t working for you, switch. If it’s working for you, don’t get tempted to choose another one just because someone else likes it better 🙂